Pigeon Forge and the greater Smokies area are filled with restaurants competing for attention, but every so often a place opens that feels genuinely rooted in purpose rather than promotion. DellaSantina Pizzeria is one of those rare finds. This family-driven pizzeria brings authentic Italian pizza traditions and true Chicago deep dish pizza to the Smokies, offering something that feels both timeless and refreshingly honest. Built on Italian heritage, Chicago influences, and a deep respect for ingredients, this new restaurant quietly stands out as one of the most memorable pizza experiences in the region.

Rather than chasing trends, DellaSantina Pizzeria focuses on craft. From the flour used in the dough to the way each pizza is baked and served, everything follows a clear philosophy. For visitors staying near Dollywood, Gatlinburg, Sevierville, or Pigeon Forge cabins, this spot offers a food experience that feels carefully considered and genuinely satisfying.

Watch this Our awesome YouTube video tour:

DellaSantina Pizzeria Review

DellaSantina Pizzeria is a family-driven Italian pizzeria located in Sevierville, just minutes from Dollywood and the heart of the Smokies. Known for authentic Chicago deep dish and traditional Italian thin-crust pizza, this restaurant focuses on quality ingredients, scratch-made sauces, and carefully crafted dough using imported Italian Caputo 00 flour.

Open Tuesday through Saturday, the pizzeria keeps a limited but thoughtfully curated menu inspired by Italian heritage and Chicago roots. Their deep-dish pizza follows traditional methods with sauce layered on top and baked longer for structure and flavor. Thin-crust options offer a lighter, balanced bite, while signature pizzas like Harlem Avenue and Gabba Ghoul highlight bold yet well-balanced combinations.

All meats are sliced in-house, cheeses are freshly shredded, and no ingredients are frozen. Gluten-free options are available using certified Italian flour with careful preparation practices.

Desserts include house-made tiramisu and imported Italian gelato, including the popular Spumoni Bomba. Whether dining in or taking pizza back to a Smokies cabin, DellaSantina Pizzeria delivers one of the most authentic and memorable pizza experiences near Pigeon Forge and Gatlinburg.

Location, Contact Information, and Hours

DellaSantina Pizzeria is located at 2004 Red Bank Road in Sevierville, Tennessee. Although the address places it in Sevierville, the restaurant sits just minutes from Pigeon Forge and Dollywood, making it extremely convenient for visitors exploring the Smokies. The drive from Dollywood takes only a short time and follows quieter back roads, which adds to the feeling of discovering a true hidden gem rather than a high-traffic tourist stop.

The restaurant can be reached by phone at 865-366-7032, and additional information is available through their official website at dellasantinapizzacom. These direct contact options are especially helpful for guests placing takeout orders or checking availability during busy travel seasons.

DellaSantina Pizzeria operates on a focused schedule that allows the team to maintain quality and consistency. The restaurant is open Tuesday through Friday from 11 AM to 9 PM, and on Saturday from 11 AM to 10 PM. The pizzeria is closed on Sundays and Mondays. These limited hours reflect the hands-on nature of the kitchen, where everything is prepared fresh rather than rushed.

Inside DellaSantina Pizzeria

Stepping inside DellaSantina Pizzeria feels less like entering a commercial restaurant and more like being welcomed into a thoughtfully run family space. The interior is clean, simple, and functional, designed around food quality rather than flashy décor. At the time of opening, seating inside is limited, with expansion underway, which makes takeout a popular choice for guests heading back to cabins or vacation rentals.

Despite its modest size, the atmosphere feels intentional. Every part of the space supports the kitchen’s workflow, allowing pizzas to be prepared with care and precision. Guests can see the attention given to cleanliness and organization, which reinforces the restaurant’s commitment to fresh, in-house preparation.

Inside the Kitchen

The kitchen at DellaSantina Pizzeria reflects the restaurant’s core values. There is no freezer, only refrigeration for fresh ingredients. Ovens are designed specifically for pizza production, and the workspace is kept meticulously clean. Every step of preparation is intentional, from dough proofing to final bake.

The Full Menu Philosophy

The menu at DellaSantina Pizzeria is not designed to overwhelm. Instead, it reflects years of experience and a clear understanding of what makes great pizza. Each item exists for a reason, whether it is inspired by Italian tradition, Chicago street culture, or personal family history. This thoughtful approach makes the menu feel curated rather than crowded.

What truly defines the menu is the ingredient philosophy behind it. The kitchen uses Italian Caputo double-zero flour for both thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas. This flour is imported from Italy and is non-genetically modified, producing dough that is light, clean, and easy to digest. Filtered water is used in dough preparation, and Galbani cheese from Italy is shredded in-house to avoid additives and preservatives.

All meats are sliced in-house, sauces are made from scratch, and nothing is pre-prepared or frozen. Even the sugar used in recipes is carefully sourced. The result is pizza that feels noticeably different from standard American pizzerias, both in flavor and in how it feels after eating.

What Makes the Pizza Different

One of the most common questions guests ask is what truly sets this pizza apart. The answer lies in restraint and respect for ingredients. Rather than piling on toppings or overwhelming the dough, each pizza is built to highlight balance. The crust provides structure without heaviness, the sauce delivers clean tomato flavor, and the toppings complement rather than compete.

For guests with gluten sensitivity, the restaurant offers gluten-free pizza made with certified Italian gluten-free flour. While the team avoids making medical claims, they are transparent about their process and the care taken to reduce cross-contamination. Separate proofing containers and clear kitchen protocols help ensure a thoughtful experience for those with sensitivities.

Signature Pizzas and Their Stories

One of the defining elements of the menu is how each signature pizza carries a story. These names are not marketing gimmicks but personal references that connect the food to real experiences.

The Harlem Avenue pizza reflects Chicago roots and features flavors inspired by classic Italian beef and jardiniera combinations. It introduces many guests to a flavor profile they may not have experienced before, especially outside of Chicago.

Another standout is the pizza featuring calamata olives, a combination inspired by personal favorites developed over years of enjoying Italian flavors. The olives add depth and richness without overpowering the balance of the pie.

Jo Jo “The Whale” is built around homemade meatballs and pays tribute to classic film references and Italian-American culture. Despite its hearty name, the pizza remains balanced and surprisingly light.

The Betrayal pizza features a house-made Alfredo sauce paired with carefully prepared chicken. The sauce is made fresh daily, creating a creamy but clean flavor that feels indulgent without being heavy.

The VFL pizza reflects family ties to the University of Tennessee and brings together flavors that resonate with local pride while maintaining the restaurant’s Italian foundation.

Claudia, named after a family member, highlights lighter toppings inspired by Italian travel experiences, combining fresh elements that feel bright and refined.

Chicago Deep Dish Pizza in the Smokies

Authentic Chicago deep-dish pizza is the centerpiece of DellaSantina Pizzeria and one of the main reasons guests seek it out. True deep dish is rare in the Smokies, and even rarer when it follows traditional methods. Here, the pizza is baked for around twenty minutes, allowing the dough to cook thoroughly while supporting a generous layer of cheese and sauce.

The sauce is made from scratch and placed on top, as tradition dictates, protecting the cheese during the long bake and creating a layered, satisfying texture. At launch, deep dish options focus on cheese and cheese with sausage, allowing guests to experience the true foundation of Chicago-style pizza.

Despite its thickness, the deep dish remains light thanks to the Italian flour used in the dough. Guests are often surprised by how clean and balanced it feels compared to expectations.

The Sauce Made from Scratch

The sauce deserves special attention because it defines much of the flavor experience. Made entirely in-house, it delivers a fresh tomato taste that is neither overly sweet nor aggressively seasoned. This balance allows the sauce to complement both thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas without dominating them.

Desserts That Complete the Experience

Desserts at DellaSantina Pizzeria are treated with the same care as the pizzas. The tiramisu is made in-house using a long-standing recipe that takes hours to prepare. The coffee flavor is balanced, the texture is carefully controlled, and each ingredient is chosen for quality.

Alongside tiramisu, the restaurant offers imported Italian gelato, including the Spumoni Bomba, a layered dessert featuring chocolate, pistachio, and cherry gelato encased in a chocolate shell. It is rich, shareable, and memorable, making it a favorite choice for guests taking dessert back to their cabins.

Gabba Ghoul Pizza Review

The Gabba Ghoul pizza is a meat-forward option featuring bacon, sausage, pepperoni, and homemade meatballs. Despite its bold appearance, the pizza maintains balance thanks to the quality of the dough and careful portioning of toppings. The crust remains crisp underneath, and the flavors come together without feeling overwhelming.

Deep Dish Pizza Review

The deep dish pizza delivers a rich but controlled experience. Each slice holds its structure while offering layers of cheese, sauce, and dough that work together rather than compete. The tomato flavor stands out, and the overall bite feels authentic and thoughtfully executed.

Dessert Reviews

The tiramisu offers a refined take on a classic dessert, avoiding overly strong coffee flavors while maintaining depth. The Spumoni Bomba adds a playful, indulgent option that feels special and unique, especially for guests looking to try something different.

Delos Centina Restaurant Connection

DellaSantina Pizzeria is connected to the broader Delos Centina restaurant family, which focuses on traditional Italian cooking with clean ingredients. This connection reinforces the philosophy seen in the pizzeria, emphasizing fresh preparation, quality sourcing, and a family-first approach to hospitality.

FAQ

Final Thoughts

DellaSantina Pizzeria is more than just a new pizza place in the Smokies. It represents a commitment to tradition, quality, and thoughtful cooking. For visitors searching for the best pizza in Pigeon Forge, authentic Italian pizza near Gatlinburg, or real Chicago deep dish pizza close to Dollywood, this pizzeria offers an experience that feels genuine and memorable. It is the kind of place that turns a simple meal into a highlight of the trip and leaves guests planning their return before they even leave town.

See More

• Gatlinburg Covered in Snow: Downtown Walk, Open Attractions, Road Conditions & Winter Scenes
• What Pigeon Forge Looks Like in Snow: Dollywood, The Island, Old Mill & Smoky Mountains
• What’s Coming in 2026 at Dollywood? New Nightflight Expedition Tour, Ride Details & Major Park Updates
• Top Things to Do in Gatlinburg & Pigeon Forge 2026 | Best Smoky Mountains Attractions Guide
• Over Easy Al’s Review | Menu, Hours & Best Brunch and Gluten-Free Breakfast in Gatlinburg TN

For more updates and insider tips, follow us on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and X!